Episodes
Dec. 4, 2025
Wrestling Rundown/Survivor Series Wargames Recap | Turnbuckle Tabloid - Episode 511
Jay and "Whole Milk" Mike break down WWE's final major PLE of the year as well discussing the wrestling news stories of the week. Links YouTube https://youtube.com/@nywrestlemedia Facebook https://www.facebook.com/NYWrestleMe...
Nov. 23, 2025
History & Headlocks: CM Punk Part 2
Class continues when Mike and Jay speak of the career of the Second City Saint. Guest speaker Ringside Ricky shares his thoughts of the man labeled The Best in the World as the discussion spans from the infamous promo to the ...
Nov. 10, 2025
Are We Talking Sports? Women & Football
Jay Santy sits down with Mahomey Mahomes to discuss the growing intrigue around women and football, as well as how to handle pushback from other fandoms. Links Follow Turnbuckle Tabloid on Twitter: https://twitter.com/Turnbuc...
Nov. 8, 2025
History & Headlocks: CM Punk Part 1
On this episode, "Whole Milk" Mike and Jay look into the early stages of CM Punk's wrestling career and the lead in to his most infamous promo. Links Follow Turnbuckle Tabloid on Twitter: https://twitter.com/TurnbuckleTab Joi...
Oct. 22, 2025
Under The Ring Apron: Bell 2 Bell
On this episode, Jay sits down with Bell 2 Bell host Blackout the Rebel to discuss the state of wrestling, changes in the business, and what it takes to run a wrestling podcast Links Follow Turnbuckle Tabloid on Twitter: http...
Oct. 13, 2025
Collar 2 Pinfall - Episode 2 | Halftime & Part Times w/ "The Keef"
This week's episode of Collar 2 Pinfall has Jay and The Keef faceoff on subject matters such as Andrade to AEW, MLB playoffs, New TV Ratings, Bad Bunny halftime and much more. Links Follow Turnbuckle Tabloid on Twitter: https...
Oct. 12, 2025
Under The Ring Apron - A Stern Look: John Cena
Jay Santy and "Whole Milk" Mike walk down memory lane and watch a 2007 episode of Howard Stern with John Cena as a guest. Links Follow Turnbuckle Tabloid on Twitter: https://twitter.com/TurnbuckleTab Join the Turnbuckle Tablo...
Sept. 26, 2025
What's A Palooza? | Turnbuckle Tabloid - Episode 510
This week, Jay recaps a jam-packed weekend of wrestling. "Whole Milk" Mike and "The Keef" sit in to discuss the WWE PLE Wrestlepalooza and AEW All Out. Links Follow Turnbuckle Tabloid on Twitter: https://twitter.com/Turnbuckl...
Sept. 20, 2025
Collar 2 Pinfall - Episode 1 | Referee Angel Cruz
On the launch episode of C2P Jay and Referee Angel Cruz discuss all things wrestling as well as sports in a speed round of questions and opinions. Links Follow Turnbuckle Tabloid on Twitter: https://twitter.com/TurnbuckleTab ...
Aug. 30, 2025
Gotta Do Business | Turnbuckle Tabloid - Episode 509
On this episode, Jay discusses the upcoming changes to Turnbuckle Tabloid and the Raja Jackson incident. Also, we see a sneak peek of a new show on the network, Under the Ring Apron, which this week covers Booker T on the How...
Aug. 10, 2025
Break Time | Turnbuckle Tabloid - Episode 508
On this week's episode, Jay discusses his reasoning for why he's taking a hiatus from WWE. Also, SummerSlam and other events of the week are discussed on Cutting A Promo. Links Follow Turnbuckle Tabloid on Twitter: https://tw...
July 21, 2025
Recap With All Respect | Turnbuckle Tabloid - Episode 507
This week is packed with full wrestling reviews. Jay sits down with "Whole Milk" Mike to discuss a weekend full of wrestling from all the major promotions, plus a breakdown of Respect the Craft's first event, "Respect" Links ...
July 1, 2025
Ringing In Royalty | Turnbuckle Tabloid - Episode 506
Night of Champions and the finals of The King and Queen of Ring is fully covered in this week's episode. Also this week, Jay discusses the troubling business practices of WWE and Cody Rhodes attempt at a podcast. Links Follow...
June 17, 2025
You Can't Handle the Truth | Turnbuckle Tabloid - Episode 505
R- Truth makes his return, and Jay has his thoughts on it and wrestling promotions not listening to fans. Also this week, Jay digs into WWE double PLE day and news from around the ring on Wrestling Rundown. Links Follow Turnb...
May 29, 2025
So Much Wrestling, So Little Time | Turnbuckle Tabloid - Episode 504
Jay covers a packed weekend of professional wrestling on this week's episode. With WWE Saturday Night Main Event, NXT Battleground, and AEW Double or Nothing taking place, Jay fills up you the listener with recaps and opinion...
May 17, 2025
Wrestling And Death | Turnbuckle Tabloid - Episode 503
In this episode, Jay Santy looks into Sabu's life and the commitment of pro wrestlers. Also, this week, Jay recaps the WWE Backlash PLE. Links Follow Turnbuckle Tabloid on Twitter: https://twitter.com/TurnbuckleTab Join the T...
May 9, 2025
Now Serving, Benjamin Shelton | Turnbuckle Tabloid - Episode 502
This week's episode is loaded with releases, signings, and Hulk Hogan lies. Jay discusses the recent WWE releases and the jam-packed news coverage on Wrestling Rundown. Links Follow Turnbuckle Tabloid on Twitter: https://twit...
April 25, 2025
You Can't Cena Me! | Turnbuckle Tabloid - Episode 501
On this week's episode, Jay discusses the career of John Cena and the main event of WrestleMania. Also, Jay and the crew recap the matches and occurrences at WrestleMania. Links Follow Turnbuckle Tabloid on Twitter: https://t...
April 12, 2025
Fresh Start | Turnbuckle Tabloid - Episode 500
Celebrating a milestone with Jay Santy and the rest of the Turnbuckle Tabloid family is a lot of work. On this monumental event, Jay talks wrestling news with Ari and Mike for Wrestling Rundown, and The Keef makes his long-aw...
April 3, 2025
Return Of The Matt | Turnbuckle Tabloid - Episode 499
One episode away from 500, Turnbuckle Tabloid's prodigal son returns. Matt the Mook sits in for an entire episode discussing the podcast's history, what's happening at Disney, and the news on Wrestling Rundown. Links Follow T...
March 26, 2025
Unfortunate Ends | Turnbuckle Tabloid - Episode 498
This week, we look at the end of a career and, unfortunately, the end of a life. Jay discusses the untimely death of Vince Steele and the retirement of Notorious 187 Homicide. Also, stick around for the history of Turnbuckle ...
March 16, 2025
For The Fans | Turnbuckle Tabloid - Episode 497
This week's wrestling news is on full tilt for Wrestling Rundown. Also in this episode, Jay sits down with author Dr. Jeremy Housewright to discuss his upcoming book For The Love of the Show II . Buy For The Love Of The Show:...
March 5, 2025
Now We See You Cena | Turnbuckle Tabloid - Episode 496
This week's episode is jam-packed with wrestling news and surprises. The crew covers Elimination Chamber, and Jay handles the coverage of Iyo Sky winning the title and all other happenings on Wrestling Rundown. Links Follow T...
Feb. 24, 2025
Lights, Camera, Tabbys! | Turnbuckle Tabloid - Episode 495
The 2025 Tabby Awards are finally here! Jay and his fellow presenters Ariana "Not The Grande" and "Whole Milk" Mike showcase the best and worst of wrestling in 2024 Links Follow Turnbuckle Tabloid on Twitter: https://twitter....